Silver is a historical color in Chincoteague Ponies. Silver (Z) is a dilution that changes the appearance of black and bay colored horses. It's also called silver dapple, chocolate (Rocky Mountain Horse term) and taffy (Australian term). The silver dilution mutation is on the PMEL17 gene. Silver is dominant, meaning it cannot skip generations. Silvers can range in color shade based upon their base color and other dilutions/modifiers. They can also go through many shade changes throughout their lifetime.
Silver Chestnut does not visibly look different than any chestnut. They look like a normal chestnut because silver does not affect red.
Silver buckskin Rocky Mountain Horse/Quarter Horse cross
Silver can combine with other colors so there's silver buckskins, silver smoky blacks, silver duns, grey silvers, pinto silvers. There's been a test for the silver dilution since 2006 but silver is quite old. It's found in Icelandic Horses which have had no crossbreeding for 1,000 years.
Many silvers are mistaken for flaxen chestnuts and vice versa. In the absence of testing; a black based offspring from seemingly chestnut parents indicates that one parent is a silver instead of a chestnut. Similarly, the silver offspring of a chestnut parent and a non-silver black based parent indicates that the chestnut parent is carrying silver.
Multiple Congenital Ocular Anomalies (MCOA) is a genetic disorder linked to silver. Heterozygous horses are not affected but homozygous silver horses are. MOCA affected horses can have multiple abnormalities of the eye including cysts, cloudy eyes, abnormal lens positions, and pop eyes. Horses with MOCA often have impaired vision and difficulties in adapting to changing light conditions.
Silver Black Shackleford Island Stallion
There are a couple early descriptions of Chincoteague Ponies that could be silver. An article in the San Francisco Chronicle from 1893 described a Chincoteague Pony that sounds a great deal like a silver, "His coat is a beautiful shade of red, lighter than bay and almost a sorrel. The mane and tails are strikingly conspicuous, being a soft, creamy, white suggestive of silky Augora wool." Silver is found in the feral herd of Shackleford Island Horses which has a similar origin story to Chincoteague Ponies.
The earliest photographic evidence of silver being introduced in Chincoteagues is a silver bay Welsh Pony named Starlight owned by Beebe Ranch in the late 1950's. Starlight's photograph appears in the Pictorial Life Story of Misty as he was bred to Misty, apparently unsuccessfully. Another possible silver from the same time period was photographed in 1956. That pony appears to be part Shetland. Silver is found in several breeds that have been crossed into the Chincoteague Pony including Morgans, Mustangs, Quarter Horses, Shetland Ponies, and Welsh Ponies.